« Nickels and Hair | Main | From humble beginnings we built our empire »
September 26, 2006
With what shall I mend it, dear Liza, dear Liza?
Purely by accident I stumbled across Robertson Davies, and then across this:
"Oh, this Christianity! Even when people swear they don't believe in it, the fifteen hundred years of Christianity that has made our world is in their bones, and they want to show they can be Christians without Christ. Those are the worst; they have the cruelty of doctrine without the poetic grace of myth."
-Robertson Davies, Fifth Business
When I first registered to vote, I registered as an independent. I don't remember if I was leaning towards Green or Libertarianism or what, but at any rate I had some clear idea of what I wanted and I was equally certain that I didn't support the Democrats. The strain of this nearly killed my poor mother. I clearly wasn't a Republican, we all knew that much. To register as anything remotely liberal was, to her thinking at the time, to register as a sort of lapsed Democrat -- so why take support away from the Democrats in favor of a weak imitation? To me, of course, it looked different: the Green Party provides things that neither Republicans or Democrats offer, and that's what I wanted. I wasn't just going to hop the first party train that traveled to the same part of the country I wanted to go, not when I knew the exact name of the town I wanted to visit.
I am often confronted with the religious equivalent of that. There seems to be a general opinion that to be aetheist in America is to be a lapsed Christian. I usually hear this from Christians, Davies being a notable example. It's funny to me that these Christians seem to feel a belief in Christ is a negligable part of their religion: I've got a moral code more or less aligned with theirs and I live in the right part of the world for it, so I must esentially be one of them. After all, aetheism is a lack, not a presence, right? So I obviously have a hole in my soul-bucket where religion should go.
The truth, of course, is that it's a belief in something different, not a non-belief -- I'm aetheist, not agnostic, and not a faded version of a Christian. There are those who don't like it, just as there are those (crazy people) who don't like my eyebrows or my giant crooked feet, but it's an unchangeable feature of me that Robertson Davies and everyone else is just going to have to accept.
Bones, schmones. There's no hole in my bucket.
Posted by didofoot at September 26, 2006 02:20 PM
Comments
Snap. Snap. Snap snap snap.
Besides being inaccurate, it also encourages people to think that if they merely fill in that minor lack of God I will then be a complete Christian. That has been in many cases all the encouragement people need to start laying the God stuff on with a heavy trowel. Little do they know that if you plaster an atheist with God stuff, what you get is actually just an atheist who really wants a shower.
Posted by: Dianna at September 26, 2006 03:14 PM
It's a really good book, though.
Posted by: jason at September 26, 2006 08:02 PM
totally. i only got so pissed off because he managed to convince me i really am a lapsed christian. hence the protesting.
Posted by: didofoot at September 27, 2006 09:30 AM
Religious people seem to misunderstand atheists quite a bit. Atheism is simply a strong commitment to the scientific method -- being skeptical of everything unless there's good reason (i.e. evidence) to believe otherwise. Since there's no scientific evidence for a diety or an afterlife, I'll remain skeptical until there's a good reason to do otherwise.
A typical response to this is "then where did everything come from? why are we here? etc.". Well, I don't know. I certainly don't think there has to be a reason for everything just because we want there to be one. I'd rather admit that I don't know the answer to something than invent a false answer to believe in.
Posted by: docta v at September 27, 2006 12:03 PM
You know, there's plenty of pre-Christian religion and mythology that has helped to shape our way of life (and, some might say, Christianity itself) as well. I'm just saying.
Posted by: matt at September 27, 2006 01:06 PM
preach on, docta v. i'm with you.
Posted by: tracy at September 27, 2006 02:49 PM
May I just chip in something. What you all seem to have missed is that I'm hiding on purpose. As you seem like interested people, I'll give you a clue. I'm hiding in a Taco Bell, and if you can find me, I'll buy you a free meal. amen.
Posted by: God at September 28, 2006 12:12 PM
Post a comment
Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)
(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)